Comparison Marmot Catalyst 2P vs MSR Elixir 2

The total weight of the tent is including the frame and other accessories.

This parameter depends primarily on the purpose (see above), and after that — on seasonality, capacity, and additional functions. For example, in trekking and expedition models, the weight usually does not exceed 5 – 7.5 kg, and the lightest of these products can weigh 2 – 3 kg or even less, while being full-fledged tents for 2 people or even more. However, for a trekking tent, such a small weight with a capacity of more than 2 people usually means that this model is designed exclusively for the summer. For most camping tents, the weight starts at 6 kg, although among them there are also quite light products — by 4 – 5 kg, 3 – 4 kg, or even less (in such cases, light weight can also mean a purely summer specialization). And the most capacious and/or multifunctional models can have a weight of 10 – 15 kg, 15 – 20 kg and even more; in this weight category, you can mainly find tents, camping tents for many people and fishing tents for carp fishing (see "Destination").

When choosing a tent according to this indicator, it is worth considering that it does not always make sense to chase the maximum weight reduction. Yes, the...light tent is the most convenient to carry; on the other hand, weight reduction inevitably affects one or several other characteristics at once. So, most often, lighter models are either more expensive or smaller in size and less roomy and functional than their heavier counterparts. And sometimes weight reduction also negatively affects the security (including moisture resistance) and the overall reliability of the product. Therefore, it makes sense to specifically look for the lightest tent possible in cases where weight reduction is of key importance; a typical example is long trips, in which all the equipment has to be carried “on oneself” for a long time. And even in such cases, it is worth remembering other important characteristics. For example, for use in late autumn, when frosts are likely, it is better to choose a heavier tent with winter seasonality than a light model that is not designed for winter conditions.

The length of the vestibule provided in the tent.

See above for more details on the vestibule. As for its dimensions, the length of the vestibule is measured along the same side along which the length of the entire tent is measured; and the width of this compartment usually corresponds to the overall width of the tent, and it does not need to be specified separately in the specifications. At the same time, we note that due to such measurement rules, the length of the vestibule is often less than its width; this is quite normal in this case.

The specific ratio between the dimensions of this compartment in different tents may be different. However, in general, a longer vestibule is usually larger and more capacious than a shorter one. When choosing, it should be taken into account that a large and spacious additional compartment increases overall comfort, but it significantly affects the price and weight of the tent (not to mention its overall dimensions). So when choosing for this parameter, it is worth considering the real conditions and features of the operation of the tent. We only note that in order to organize additional beds, it is worth paying attention to vestibules with a length of at least 150 cm — usually, they can accommodate additional places at least across, and often along the tent.

— PU (polyurethane). A polyurethane (PU) coating is applied to the inside of the outer tent. The protective layer of polyurethane increases the moisture resistance of the tent, at the same time, the strength of the awning fabric also increases. The main advantage of polyurethane is the ability to reliably protect seam joints. However, polyurethane protection is not the most effective, besides, the presence increases the weight of the tent. The use of polyurethane protection alone is more typical for entry-level (low-cost) class tents. In good quality tents, PU coating is complemented by other types of protection, often polyurethane is used together with silicone (Si).

— Si (silicone). The outer tent fabric is impregnated with silicone (Si). Silicone significantly increases the moisture resistance of the tent. The fabric impregnated with silicone acquires elasticity, its strength characteristics increase. This type of protection is considered the most technologically advanced and functional. The tent itself is impregnated with silicone (from the outside), and sometimes a PU coating is additionally made from the inside for better water resistance. The main disadvantage is the inability to protect seam joints. For this reason, the seams in silicone impregnated tents are glued separately.

— Polyester. Synthetic material with good durability and waterproof performance. In addition, it is resistant to adverse effects (does not lose strength when wet, exposed to acidic and alkaline environments, temperature changes).

— Nylon. In general, the characteristics of nylon are somewhat lower than those of polyester: it tends to stretch when wet and is generally less resistant to adverse effects. At the same time, given that most owners use tents in relatively simple conditions, these points are not critical; in addition, some manufacturers use a special treatment to improve the durability of nylon.

— Polyethylene. This material is mainly used in inexpensive models of camping tents (see "Purpose") — this is primarily due to its significant weight. For other characteristics, it does not have key differences from other materials.

— Polyamide. The general name for a class of fabrics, which includes, in particular, nylon and nylon. Some manufacturers use this term for marketing purposes: "polyamide" sounds more solid than "nylon", although these materials practically do not differ in characteristics and are used in the same way — mainly in inexpensive models.

An indicator that reflects the degree of resistance of the bottom of the tent to moisture. For more information about the features of measuring this indicator, see "Tent waterproofness". Here also note that, for obvious reasons, the bottom, unlike an awning, is practically not subject to rain drops — as a result, the requirements for bottom water resistance are significantly lower. So, fabrics with a water resistance of 3000 mm of water. Art. are considered absolutely waterproof (up to the possibility of putting a tent in a puddle), and higher values usually indicate an increased thickness of the fabric and corresponding strength and wear resistance. Just like with an awning, more waterproof fabrics tend to have a significant amount of weight, so it doesn't always make sense to look for bottoms with maximum water resistance.

The corners of the tent are one of the "critical" places: in the unfolded state, they have almost the greatest stress, and the fabric in this place can be torn. To avoid this, many tents are equipped with reinforced corners. In this case, strength can be increased due to multi-layer sewing, special fabric or additional firmware.

— Reflective Elements. The outer surface of the tent is equipped with special reflective inserts. This ensures that the tent's location is noticeable from a distance, allowing users to easily find it at night by identifying the campsite/tent's position. Reflective threads are often woven into guy lines to prevent tripping in the dark.

— Mosquito Net. A fine mesh covering the tent's openings: entrances, windows, ventilation gaps. Having it is strongly recommended if you plan to use the tent in warm weather: it allows ventilation inside while keeping mosquitoes and other unpleasant flying insects out.

— Lantern Loop. A special fixture (loop, hook, or carabiner) usually located under the ceiling, intended for securing a lantern inside the tent. It allows you to easily organize interior lighting without the need to hold a flashlight or find a place for it.

— Internal Pockets. Pockets located on the inside of the tent. They help organize interior space, allowing you to conveniently place relatively small items—glasses, watches, certain tools, etc. Moreover, it reduces the risk of accidentally crushing fragile items.

— Shelf for Small Items. The purpose of the hanging shelf is similar to internal pockets (see above): to organize the space inside the tent so that small ite...ms are not lost or accidentally crushed. Some tents may have multiple shelves. Shelves are usually located at the top of the tent, making them useful as a lantern stand if a loop for it (see above) is not available or cannot be used for some reason.

— Cable Port. A special small slit or flap in the tent's wall designed for the neat and safe insertion of an electrical cable inside. This feature allows you to connect lighting, chargers, or other devices directly inside the tent without compromising its waterproofness and protection from rain. The port is usually covered with a Velcro, zipper, or special plug, to ensure the tent remains fully sealed in the absence of a cable. This detail is particularly useful at campsites with electricity access and makes the tent more comfortable and modern to use.

The volume of a tent when folded helps understand how convenient it is to transport it in a trunk, store it at home, or take it on a hiking trip, cycling tour, or backpacking adventure. The smaller the volume in liters, the more compact the tent is when packed.

For example, a trekking model with a volume of about 6 – 10 L easily fits into a 40 – 50 L hiking backpack without taking up too much valuable space. A 10 – 15 L tent can also fit in a backpack, but usually requires tighter packing and is generally better suited for backpacks of 50 – 65 L. If the volume is 15 – 20 L or more, such a tent is often more conveniently attached outside, especially when space inside needs to be reserved for a sleeping bag, clothes, and other items. Camping tents, although they may not have a large volume, primarily find their place in a car trunk where volume matters less.