USA
Catalog   /   Computing   /   Components   /   Computer Cooling

Comparison Noctua NF-S12A PWM vs Noctua NF-P12 PWM

Add to comparison
Noctua NF-S12A PWM
Noctua NF-P12 PWM
Noctua NF-S12A PWMNoctua NF-P12 PWM
Compare prices 2Compare prices 1
TOP sellers
Main specs
Featuresfor casefor case
Product typefanfan
Fan
Number of fans11
Fan size120 mm120 mm
Fan thickness25 mm25 mm
Bearing
magnetic centring /SSO2/
magnetic centring /SSO2/
Max. RPM1200 rpm1300 rpm
Speed controller
auto (PWM) /+ adapter - resistor/
auto (PWM) /+ adapter/
Max. air flow63 CFM54 CFM
MTBF150 K hours150 K hours
Noise level18 dB20 dB
Power source4-pin4-pin
General
Mount typesilicone mountssilicone mounts
Dimensions120x120x25 mm120x120x25 mm
Added to E-Catalogseptember 2013may 2012

Max. RPM

The highest speed at which the cooling system fan is capable of operating; for models without a speed controller (see below), this item indicates the nominal rotation speed. In the "slowest" modern fans, the maximum speed does not exceed 1000 rpm, in the "fastest" it can be up to 2500 rpm and even more.

Note that this parameter is closely related to the fan diameter (see above): the smaller the diameter, the higher the speed must be to achieve the desired airflow values. In this case, the rotation speed directly affects the level of noise and vibration. Therefore, it is believed that the required volume of air is best provided by large and relatively "slow" fans; and it makes sense to use "fast" small models where compactness is crucial. If we compare the speed of models of the same size, then higher speeds have a positive effect on performance, but increase not only the noise level, but also the price and power consumption.

Max. air flow

The maximum airflow that a cooling fan can create; measured in CFM — cubic feet per minute.

The higher the CFM number, the more efficient the fan. On the other hand, high performance requires either a large diameter (which affects the size and cost) or high speed (which increases the noise and vibration levels). Therefore, when choosing, it makes sense not to chase the maximum air flow, but to use special formulas that allow you to calculate the required number of CFM depending on the type and power of the cooled component and other parameters. Such formulas can be found in special sources. As for specific numbers, in the most modest systems, the performance does not exceed 30 CFM, and in the most powerful systems it can be up to 80 CFM and even more.

It is also worth considering that the actual value of the air flow at the highest speed is usually lower than the claimed maximum; see Static Pressure for details.

Noise level

The standard noise level generated by the cooling system during operation. Usually, this paragraph indicates the maximum noise during normal operation, without overloads and other "extreme".

Note that the noise level is indicated in decibels, and this is a non-linear value. So it is easiest to evaluate the actual loudness using comparative tables. Here is a table for values found in modern cooling systems:

20 dB — barely audible sound (quiet whisper of a person at a distance of about 1 m, sound background in an open field outside the city in calm weather);
25 dB — very quiet (normal whisper at a distance of 1 m);
30 dB — quiet (wall clock). It is this noise that, according to sanitary standards, is the maximum allowable for constant sound sources at night (from 23.00 to 07.00). This means that if the computer is planned to sit at night, it is desirable that the volume of the cooling system does not exceed this value.
35 dB — conversation in an undertone, sound background in a quiet library;
40 dB — conversation, relatively quiet, but already in full voice. The maximum permissible noise level for residential premises in the daytime, from 7.00 to 23.00, according to sanitary standards. However, even the noisiest cooling systems usually do not reach this indicator, the maximum for such equipment is about 38 – 39 dB.
Noctua NF-S12A PWM often compared
Noctua NF-P12 PWM often compared