USA
Catalog   /   Automotive   /   Car Audio   /   Car Subwoofers

Comparison Alphard Magnum M15D4 vs Magnum MBW 15-24SF

Add to comparison
Alphard Magnum M15D4
Magnum MBW 15-24SF
Alphard Magnum M15D4Magnum MBW 15-24SF
from $103.22 up to $111.48
Outdated Product
Expecting restock
TOP sellers
Application areacarcar
Designwithout bodyFreeAir (without case)
Typepassivepassive
Size15" (38 cm)15" (38 cm)
Tech specs
Rated power350 W1000 W
Max. power
1000 W /Peak/
2000 W
Frequency range28 – 550 Hz
Sensitivity88 dB90 dB
Dual voice coil
Impedance
4 ohm /single coil/
4 ohm /single coil/
Resonant frequency33,4 Hz
General
Diffuser materialpulp / paperpulp / paper
Woofer Diameter380 mm380 mm
Added to E-Catalogmarch 2016september 2014

Design

In the body. Subwoofers consisting of a full-fledged enclosure in which the speaker (speakers) is installed. Usually they are designed to be installed in the boot. Cabinet models are easy to install, but take up a significant amount of space, and in most cases have some phase delay that requires phase adjustment (see below) to synchronize with the front speakers.

Without body. This category includes subwoofers designed to work in their own cabinet, but not equipped with it (not to be confused with Free Air — see below). Thus, having bought such a speaker, you can choose a case for it at your discretion — or even make it yourself. This, of course, is more difficult than immediately acquiring a cabinet “subwoofer”, however, it gives more opportunities for adjusting the acoustics to personal preferences. Other advantages and disadvantages of frameless models are similar to case models.

Without body (Free Air). Car subwoofers of this type are not only not equipped with a case, but they do not imply its use at all: usually Free Air models are designed for installation in the rear shelf or back of the rear seat, and the boot plays the role of the case. The advantages of such an installation are the minimum space occupied (which is important with small boot volumes), as well as the almost complete absence of delay and the ease of “docking” with the main c...hannels of the audio system. On the other hand, installing a Free Air subwoofer in itself is associated with a number of difficulties. For example, for the effective operation of such a speaker, the boot must be hermetically separated from the passenger compartment; it is quite difficult to provide such conditions, and in some body types (for example, station wagons) it is almost impossible. In addition, such a speaker has much less ability to adjust to a specific interior than a cabinet one; and with a tightly loaded boot, the sound characteristics deteriorate noticeably. Therefore, paying attention to such “subs” is primarily for owners of sedans who do not have to carry a lot of luggage.

Rated power

The average (root mean square — RMS) power of the input signal, at which the subwoofer is able to work continuously without negative consequences (damage, failure) for at least an hour. The rated power of the subwoofer must be greater than the power of the amplifier connected to it — in order to avoid overloads.

Max. power

The maximum signal power that the subwoofer is able to withstand for a short time (up to several seconds) without any negative consequences. When selecting an amplifier-subwoofer pair, it is recommended to take a subwoofer with a maximum power of at least twice the maximum power of the amplifier. In general, the higher the maximum power, the more resistant the subwoofer is to overloads.

Frequency range

The range of audio frequencies reproduced by the subwoofer. It is believed that the human ear is capable of perceiving a frequency range of the order of 16 – 20,000 Hz, but in this case note that the subwoofer is designed to reproduce the lower frequency band (up to 200 Hz). Accordingly, in the case of the lower limit of the range, everything is simple: “the lower, the better”; the upper one should not be lower than the lower limit of the main car audio — otherwise there will be "gaps" in the frequencies, which will affect the sound quality.

Sensitivity

Sensitivity determines the loudness of the subwoofer when a signal of a certain power is connected to it: with equal signal power and impedance (see below), the subwoofer with the higher sensitivity will sound louder.

Resonant frequency

The natural frequency of the cone in the subwoofer speaker, namely the frequency with which the cone will oscillate if the speaker is suspended freely in the air and a single impulse is transmitted to the cone (for example, by clicking on it with your finger). In subwoofers, this parameter determines, in particular, the lower limit of the frequency range (see above): at frequencies below the resonant sound power drops sharply. Accordingly, for deep rich bass, the resonant frequency should be as low as possible. This parameter is also used to calculate the size of the enclosure for the subwoofer.
Alphard Magnum M15D4 often compared