USA
Catalog   /   Home & Renovation   /   Autonomous Power Supply   /   Generators

Comparison Walter Stahl PR8500WS vs Edon PT 3300

Add to comparison
Walter Stahl PR8500WS
Edon PT 3300
Walter Stahl PR8500WSEdon PT 3300
Outdated Product
from $205.20 up to $226.68
Outdated Product
TOP sellers
Main
Electric starter. 400 V and 230 V sockets. 12 V output.
Fuelpetrolpetrol
Output voltage230 and 400 V230 B
Rated power2.2 kW3 kW
Max. power2.5 kW3.3 kW
Alternatorsynchronoussynchronous
Alternator windingaluminium
Engine
ICE type4-stroke4-stroke
Engine size210 cm³
Power6.5 hp7 hp
Starter typeelectric starter (key)manual
Fuel tank volume15 L15 L
Fuel level indicator
Motor coolingairair
Connection (sockets)
Total number of sockets42
Sockets 230 V16 A x316 A x2
Sockets 400 V16 A x1
Output 12 Vsocketterminals
Features
Features
 
voltmeter
automatic voltage regulator (AVR)
voltmeter
General
Protection levelIP 23
Noise level67 dB
Dimensions600x440x430 mm610x445x440 mm
Weight38 kg46 kg
Added to E-Catalognovember 2022may 2015

Output voltage

Nominal voltage at the generator output.

230 V Standard voltage of a regular household socket. It is widely used in everyday life, and there are many 230 V devices among specialized equipment; the only exception is powerful equipment (mainly from 4-5 kW), for which this voltage is no longer enough. It is 230-volt generators that should be considered by tech looking for a device for backup power supply of a residential premises or a small office.

400 V Generators capable of delivering three-phase power with a voltage of 400 V. Such power is extremely rarely used in everyday life, but it may be required for heavy equipment, specialized tools and other similar loads. Generators with an output voltage of 400 V are generally more powerful, heavier, larger, more expensive and more "gluttonous" than 230-volt ones. It is worth specifically looking for such a unit only in cases where the presence of three-phase power is essential.

230 and 400 V Combined power supply models — most generators with a three-phase output voltage of 400 V are also equipped with single-phase 230 V sockets. This ensures their universal use both for backup power supply of a home or office, and for performing more resource-intensive tasks (for example, in construction and repair, for autonomous operation of high-power loads, etc.).

— 110 V. Generators with 110...V sockets (or 120 V for certain regions). This voltage is found in household electrical networks in some countries of North and Central America, Japan, Saudi Arabia, and occasionally in Great Britain. It is not recommended to connect 230 V equipment to such sockets (unless otherwise specified in the technical documentation for a specific electrical appliance).

— DC (48 V). Models with one or more DC connectors for powering external devices with direct current. The standard DC socket is round and has a pin in the center, but its depth and diameter may vary. The voltages output to the DC output may vary — in this case, 48 V is implied.

Rated power

The nominal power of a generator is the highest power that the unit can supply without problems for an unlimited period of time. In the “weakest” models, this figure is < 1 kW, in the most powerful ones – 50–100 kW and even more ; and generators with welding capabilities (see below) usually have a nominal power from 1–2 kW to 8–10 kW.

The main rule of choice in this case is as follows: the nominal power must not be lower than the total power consumption of the entire connected load. Otherwise, the generator will simply not be able to produce enough energy, or will work with overloads. However, to determine the minimum required generator power, it is not enough to simply add up the number of watts indicated in the characteristics of each connected device - the calculation method is somewhat more complicated. Firstly, it should be taken into account that only the active power of various equipment is usually indicated in watts; in addition, many AC electrical appliances consume reactive power ("useless" power consumed by coils and capacitors when working with such power). And the actual load on the generator depends on the total power (active plus reactive), indicated in volt-amperes. There are special coefficients and formulas for its calculation.

The second nuance is related to the power su...pply of devices in which the starting power (and, accordingly, the power consumption at the moment of switching on) is significantly higher than the nominal one - these are mainly devices with electric motors such as vacuum cleaners, refrigerators, air conditioners, power tools, etc. You can determine the starting power by multiplying the standard power by the so-called starting coefficient. For equipment of the same type, it is more or less the same - for example, 1.2 - 1.3 for most power tools, 2 for a microwave oven, 3.5 for an air conditioner, etc.; more detailed data can be found in special sources. Starting load characteristics are necessary primarily to assess the required maximum generator power (see below) - however, this power is not always given in the characteristics, often the manufacturer indicates only the nominal power of the unit. In such cases, when calculating for equipment with a starting coefficient of more than 1, it is worth using the starting power, not the nominal power.

Also note that if there are several sockets, the specific division of the total power between them may be different. This point should be clarified separately - in particular, for specific types of sockets (for more details, see "230 V sockets", "400 V sockets").

Max. power

The maximum power output that the generator can provide.

This power is slightly higher than the nominal (see above), but the maximum performance mode can only be maintained for a very short time - otherwise an overload occurs. Therefore, the practical meaning of this characteristic is mainly to describe the efficiency of the generator when working with increased starting currents.

Let us recall that some types of electrical appliances consume several times more power (and, accordingly, power) at the moment of starting than in the normal mode; this is typical mainly for devices with electric motors, such as power tools, refrigerators, etc. However, increased power for such equipment is needed only for a short time, normal operation is restored in literally a few seconds. And you can estimate the starting characteristics by multiplying the nominal power by the so-called starting coefficient. For equipment of the same type, it is more or less the same (1.2 - 1.3 for most power tools, 2 for a microwave oven, 3.5 for an air conditioner, etc.); more detailed data is available in special sources.

Ideally, the maximum power of the generator should be no less than the total peak power of the connected load - that is, the starting power of equipment with a starting factor greater than 1 plus the rated power of all other equipment. This will minimize the likelihood of overloads.

Alternator winding

Copper. Copper winding is typical for advanced class generators. The copper alternator is characterized by high conductivity and low resistance. The conductivity of copper is 1.7 times higher than the conductivity of aluminium, such a winding heats up less, and compounds made of this metal endure temperature drops and vibration loads. Among the disadvantages of the copper winding, one can only note the high cost of the alternator. Otherwise, generators with copper winding have high reliability and durability.

— Aluminium. The aluminium winding of the alternator is typical for low-cost-class generators. The main advantages of aluminium are light weight and low price; otherwise, such a winding is usually inferior to copper counterparts. An oxide film is created on the surface of aluminium, it appears everywhere, even in the places of contact soldering. The oxide film undermines the contacts and does not allow the outer protective braid to securely hold the aluminium conductors.

Engine size

The working volume of the engine in a gasoline or diesel generator (see "Fuel"). Theoretically, more volume usually means more power, but in fact, everything is not so clear. Firstly, the specific power strongly depends on the type of fuel, and in gasoline units, also on the type of internal combustion engine (see above). Secondly, similar engines of the same power can have different volumes, and there is a practical point here: with the same power, a larger engine consumes more fuel, but by itself it can cost less.

Power

The operating power of the engine installed in the generator. Traditionally stated in horsepower; 1 HP approximately equal to 735 watts.

First of all, the rated power of the generator directly depends on this indicator (see above): in principle, it cannot be higher than the engine power, moreover, part of the engine power is spent on heat, friction and other losses. And the smaller the difference between these capacities, the higher the efficiency of the generator and the more economical it is. However high efficiency affects the cost, but this difference can pay off with regular use due to fuel savings.

Starter type

Method of starting the electric generator engine. To start the internal combustion engine (petrol or diesel, see "Fuel"), it is necessary to turn the engine shaft in any case; this can be done in two ways:

Manual. With this method of starting, the initial impulse is transmitted to the engine manually - usually the user needs to pull hard on the cable that spins a special flywheel. The simplest in design and cheapest method of starting, from additional equipment it requires only the cable itself with a flywheel. On the other hand, it may require the user to apply significant muscular effort and is poorly suited for high-power units.

Electric starter. With this type of start, the engine shaft is rotated by a special electric motor, which is called a starter; the starter is powered by its own battery. This option for starting the generator power unit is the easiest for the user and requires a minimum of effort. Depending on the implementation of the electric starter, it is usually enough to turn the key in the ignition switch, press a button, turn the handle or rotate a special drum, etc. The power of modern starters is sufficient even for heavy engines, where manual starting is difficult or impossible. Also note that an electric starter is required by definition to use the ATS autostart (see "Features"). On the other hand, additional equipment affects the weight and cost of the unit,...and sometimes quite noticeably. Therefore, such starting systems are used mainly where they cannot be avoided - in the aforementioned heavy equipment, as well as generators with ATS.

Total number of sockets

The total number of sockets for 230 and/or 400 V provided in the design of the generator.

This number corresponds to the number of devices that can be simultaneously connected to the generator without using splitters, extension cords, etc. If it is a three-phase model (see "Output voltage") with different types of sockets, it is worth specifying the quantity of each type separately, as different models may have varying configurations. For example, a unit specified as having 3 sockets might have 1 three-phase socket and 2 single-phase ones, or 2 three-phase and 1 single-phase socket. Generally, the most basic modern generators have only 1 socket, though models with 2 sockets are more common; and the most powerful models can have 4 or more sockets.

It is also important to remember that the ability to connect various devices is limited not only by the number of sockets but also by the generator's rated power (see above for more details).

Sockets 230 V

The number of 230 V sockets provided in the design of the generator, as well as the type of connectors used in such sockets.

The type of connector in this case is indicated by the maximum power that is allowed for the outlet - for example, “2 pieces for 16 A”. The most popular options for 230-volt outlets are 16 A, 32 A, and 63 A. We emphasize that amperes in this designation are not the actual power that the generator can produce, but the outlet’s own limitation; the actual power value is usually noticeably lower. Simply put, if, for example, the generator has a 32 A socket, the output power on it will not reach 32 A; and the specific number of amperes will depend on the rated and maximum power of the unit (see above). So, if for our example we take a rated power of 5 kW and a maximum of 6 kW, then to a 230 V outlet such a generator will be able to produce no more than 5 kW / 230 V = 22.7 A standard and 6 kW / 230 V = 27, 3 A at its peak. And if the power has to be divided between several outlets, then it will accordingly be even less.

As for specific types of connectors, the higher the power permissible for the outlet, the higher the requirements for its reliability and quality of protection. In light of this, as a rule, higher power outlets can be connected to lower power plugs (directly or through an adapter), but not vice versa. And if there are several sockets, by their type it i...s possible to estimate with some certainty the distribution of the entire power of the generator between them: between two identical sockets such power is usually divided equally, and more power is allocated to an socket with a larger number of amperes and power. However, specific details on this matter should be clarified separately in each case; It's also worth considering 400V outlets, if available (see below).
Edon PT 3300 often compared